tomspark wrote:
Claude got it right on this one — Surfshark just doesn't offer port forwarding at all, and there's no qBittorrent setting that can work around it. Without it, other people can't start connections to your box, so on a private tracker (where lots of seeders are in the same boat) torrents sit stalled. Your laptop test off the VPN proves it. So if the private tracker matters to you, switching is honestly the answer — Proton works well with SparkBox and does support port forwarding. One gotcha when you set it up: when you generate the WireGuard config on Proton's site, turn ON "NAT-PMP (Port Forwarding)" and pick a P2P server (the double-arrow icon), or forwarding won't work. Happy to walk you through it if you make the jump.